Reading Too Far Between the Lines

Finding offence where it simply isn’t intended is becoming an inherent problem in today’s society. As one news reporter put it, “people seem to be tuned into ‘Offence FM’, constantly looking for offence in meaningless comments”

Four weeks ago, David Moyes, the manager of Sunderland F.C, was accused of sexism after making a joke to a news reporter in an interview after a football match (which ended with a 0-0 draw). In the interview in question, Moyes was asked by the female reporter if the presence of the club’s owner Ellis Short had put extra pressure on him. He said it hadn’t but, after the interview, added that the interviewer “might get a slap even though you’re a woman” and told her to be “careful” next time she visited (link to the video at the bottom). Both the reporter and the manager laughed to each other and no offence was taken at the time. Later on, Moyes felt that what he said was wrong, and contacted the BBC to apologise to the journalist for his comments.

Four weeks later, Moyes’ comments are appearing in the papers and on TV, alongside headlines screaming that his words had ‘undertones of domestic violence’ and that he should lose his job.

I have no words. (except for the ones im writing here. obviously.)

I still can’t understand how the public and the media has managed to make a huge scandal out of a bit of banter between a manager and a journalist, Moyes apologised before the media even picked up the story. My biggest problem with this is that the reporter herself had no problems with the comment, and was laughing with the manager at the time. Also, in what way was the comment even offensive?

“you might get a slap even though you’re a woman”

Isn’t he saying that he would slap anyone, regardless of their gender? In that case, isn’t that the opposite of sexist, since he wouldn’t differentiate between a male and female reporter?

To be honest, I think that making big headlines out of the tiniest comments is doing injustice to actual sexist comments and actual threats of violence towards women, people are wasting time and money making stories about throw-away comments made by high profile people and are turning a blind eye to instances of real domestic violence.

Clearly, there are instances where comments are unacceptable (eg. “Grab ‘em by the p***y”, we all know who said that one), and in these cases it’s only right that the public and media speaks up against those people. And clearly, sexism is a problem in the workplace for many women, and I’m not denying that. But its not fair that men must feel like they’re walking on eggshells every time they say something in the vicinity of a woman.

Would the media have had the same reaction if the manager said something similar to a young, male reporter?

Another clear example of this is the 2014 John Lewis Christmas ad, titled ‘Monty the Penguin’. (There’s a link at the bottom for those of you who haven’t seen it before) The adorable ad featured a young boy who’s best friend was his little penguin. One day, whilst sitting watching tv together, the penguin sees a couple holding hands and becomes obsessed with the idea of being in love. The commercial ends with the boy buying his penguin a female counterpart, so that they could be happy together. The advert was a hit (as is always the case with the John Lewis X-mas advert), and yet social media lit up with people saying that the ad taught children that women exist to make men happy.

I mean… Really? Since when were kids so good at inferring non existent messages from TV adverts?

Going back to the quote from the beginning of this post (said by a female news reporter) – “people seem to be tuned into ‘Offence FM’, constantly looking for offence,” – I think that’s probably the best way I’ve heard someone describe the situation we’re in. People are actively seeking out offence in every little comment, advert and song, and if you go out seeking offence like that, you are bound to find it. The ability of some people to stretch and contort events so out of shape all for the purpose of a social media uproar or another headline is having a damaging effect on our society, and is something I think needs to change. Less people need to tune into‘Offence FM’, and more people need to tune into ‘Just get on with life FM’.

Moyes interview – https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ODq51JZ2eRg

John Lewis ad – https://www.theguardian.com/business/video/2014/nov/06/monty-penguin-john-lewis-christmas-advert-video

Advertisements

9 thoughts on “Reading Too Far Between the Lines

  1. Hey! I’d already read this post once. I read it again and I read every word as if it were my first time. It’s so freaking good!
    Keep up the good work!

    Like

    • Haha thanks so much! People seem to like this post and the ‘can money buy you happiness?’ posts the most… the most recent one isn’t doing so well (lol) I think I need to think of some more topics like this! (Do you think its the topic I chose that makes less people like the new post or the writing style?) Thanks again!

      Liked by 1 person

      • I’m gonna go and read your latest one now and I’ll let you know! 😀

        I forgot to press send and was reading on another tab… I spent like 4 hours in reading that post, I’ll tell you why in the comments there.

        Like

  2. While I agree people can make a big fuss over nothing. There is no reading between the lines on that one. He made a threat of physical violence in the form of a joke. If we lived in the world where physical abuse against women wasn’t a thing, and one where elements of the football industry didn’t have sexist attitudes towards women it wouldn’t be an issue. Yes the intent matters but the context and setting also matter. That doesn’t mean people should be going on and on about for weeks but it’s worth highlighting so people don’t do it.

    Like

  3. Came to this from community pool I agree people try to find offence. Sometimes people complain. About post watershed programmes on tv that they have found something offensive. But it’s like if that is not your type of thing switch to another channel or turn off. We are not in era of 3 or 4 channels! Don’t watch something with view to finding something to complain about,

    I came to the pool trying to work out how to categorise posts under different menus.

    Also I’m hosting a Shakespearean blog party but can not get people to interact. Nearly 1000 follower is impressive, do many interact?

    Like

  4. I totally agree with the post. Its like people are looking to get offended these days. It’s kind of annoying. Anything you say could hurt someone. Nowadays, you just cant say what you feel without hurting at least one person.
    I think instead of trying to get offended, people should try and understand what a person is trying to convey by their message and try to understand why they would’ve come to such a conclusion.

    Like

  5. Full of truth, i like your approach. I often read between the lines and it can be painful. The best way is staking things as they come without analysing or anything.
    thanks for the post!

    Like

  6. Yes, I agree, social media, and the modern times – in which the pendulum has swung, has made for some ridiculous victim posturing among some demographics in our society. Please – I’m not saying that sexist or racist comments are ok, they aren’t but it would seem that things have gone a little too far with some of the bullshit that gets peddled about, just saying.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s